M. Rooses, Rubens, vol. III, 1890, pp. 19, 32-33; S. Alpers, The Decoration of the Torre de la Parada, in Corpus Rubenianum, Ludwig Burchard, vol. IX, 1971, pp. 211-12, cat. no. 24a; M. Jaffé, "The Oil Sketches of Rubens", in Apollo, vol. CXV, no. 239, January 1982, pp. 61-65, reproduced fig. 1 and in color plate VIII; Pierre-Paul Rubens, exhibition catalog, Tokyo, Gallery Takashimaya, Yamaguchi, Prefectoral Museum; Tsu, Prefectoral Museum; and Kyoto, Gallery Takashimaya, 8 August 1985 - 20 January 1986, cat. no. 59, reproduced in color on p. 144; M. Jaffé, Rubens, Milan 1990, p. 357, cat. no. 1271, reproduced; S. Lloyd, Richard and Maria Cosway, Regency artists of taste and fashion, exhibition catalogue, Edinburgh, Scottish National Portrait Gallery; and London, National Portrait Gallery, 1995-96, p. 130, cat. no. 190, reproduced plate 79.